TYPO3 im Vergleich mit Joomla und Imperia
Trotz einer Marktführerschaft von TYPO3 unter den Open Source CMS mit 43%, werden wir oft um einen Vergleich zu anderen CMS gebeten. Hierbei gilt das Interesse sowohl der Gegenüberstellung zu proprietären Systemen mit Lizenzgebühren, als auch dem Vergeleich mit Open Source Lösungen.
Deshalb möchten wir Ihnen hier in einer Tabelle kompakt eine Gegenüberstellung zeigen. Neben TYPO3 vergleichen wir als weitere Open Source Lösung Joomla wie auch Imperia mit Lizenzgebühren von ca. 14.000 Euro. Ein als Free Add On bezeichnetes Feature bedeutet bei allen Systemen immer noch einen zusätzlichen indivuellen Anpassungsaufwand.
TYPO3 4.2.6 |
Joomla! 1.5.10 |
Imperia 8 |
|
| Application Server | PHP 5.2+ | Any that supports PHP (Apache recommended) | (optional) |
| Approximate Cost | Free | Free | 14000+ € |
| Database | MySQL, PostGreSQL, Oracle, MSSQL | MySQL | optional: Oracle, Postgres, MySQL, MSSQL, Tamino (XML) |
| License | GNU GPL | GNU/GPL v2 | Commercial, includes full source code |
| Operating System | Any | Any | Any |
| Programming Language | PHP | PHP | Perl, Java, C++, Javascipt |
| Root Access | No | No | No |
| Shell Access | No | No | Yes |
| Web Server | Apache, IIS | Apache | Any |
| Security | TYPO3 4.2.6 | Joomla! 1.5.10 | Imperia 8 |
| Audit Trail | Yes | No | Yes |
| Content Approval | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Granular Privileges | Yes | No | Yes |
| Kerberos Authentication | Free Add On | No | Yes |
| LDAP Authentication | Free Add On | Yes | Yes |
| Login History | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| NIS Authentication | Free Add On | No | Limited |
| NTLM Authentication | Free Add On | No | Limited |
| Pluggable Authentication | Free Add On | Yes | Yes |
| Problem Notification | Yes | No | Limited |
| Sandbox | Yes | No | Yes |
| Session Management | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| SMB Authentication | Free Add On | No | Limited |
| SSL Compatible | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| SSL Logins | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| SSL Pages | Free Add On | Yes | Yes |
| Versioning | Yes | Free Add On | Yes |
| Support | TYPO3 4.2.6 | Joomla! 1.5.10 | Imperia 8 |
| Certification Program | Yes | No | Yes |
| Commercial Manuals | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Commercial Support | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Commercial Training | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Developer Community | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Online Help | Yes | Yes | Limited |
| Pluggable API | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Professional Hosting | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Professional Services | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Public Forum | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Public Mailing List | Yes | No | Yes |
| Third-Party Developers | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Users Conference | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Ease of Use | TYPO3 4.2.6 | Joomla! 1.5.10 | Imperia 8 |
| Drag-N-Drop Content | Free Add On | No | Limited |
| Email To Discussion | Free Add On | Free Add On | Costs Extra |
| Friendly URLs | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Macro Language | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Server Page Language | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Spell Checker | Yes | No | Costs Extra |
| Subscriptions | Free Add On | Costs Extra | Limited |
| Template Language | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| UI Levels | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Undo | Yes | No | Yes |
| WYSIWYG Editor | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Performance | TYPO3 4.2.6 | Joomla! 1.5.10 | Imperia 8 |
| Advanced Caching | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Database Replication | Free Add On | No | Yes |
| Load Balancing | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Page Caching | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Static Content Export | Free Add On | No | Yes |
| Management | TYPO3 4.2.6 | Joomla! 1.5.10 | Imperia 8 |
| Advertising Management | Free Add On | Yes | Costs Extra |
| Asset Management | Yes | Yes | Costs Extra |
| Clipboard | Yes | No | No |
| Content Scheduling | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Content Staging | Free Add On | No | Yes |
| Inline Administration | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Online Administration | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Package Deployment | Yes | No | Yes |
| Sub-sites / Roots | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Themes / Skins | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Trash | Free Add On | Yes | Yes |
| Web Statistics | Free Add On | Yes | Free Add On |
| Web-based Style/Template Management | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Web-based Translation Management | Yes | Free Add On | Yes |
| Workflow Engine | Limited | No | Yes |
| Interoperability | TYPO3 4.2.6 | Joomla! 1.5.10 | Imperia 8 |
| Content Syndication (RSS) | Yes | Yes | Limited |
| FTP Support | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| UTF-8 Support | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| WAI Compliant | Free Add On | No | Limited |
| WebDAV Support | Free Add On | No | Yes |
| XHTML Compliant | Yes | No | Yes |
| Flexibility | TYPO3 4.2.6 | Joomla! 1.5.10 | Imperia 8 |
| CGI-mode Support | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Content Reuse | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Extensible User Profiles | Free Add On | Yes | Yes |
| Interface Localization | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Metadata | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Multi-lingual Content | Yes | Free Add On | Yes |
| Multi-lingual Content Integration | Yes | Free Add On | Yes |
| Multi-Site Deployment | Yes | Free Add On | Yes |
| URL Rewriting | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Built-in Applications | TYPO3 4.2.6 | Joomla! 1.5.10 | Imperia 8 |
| Blog | Free Add On | Yes | No |
| Chat | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Classifieds | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Contact Management | Free Add On | Yes | No |
| Data Entry | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Database Reports | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Discussion / Forum | Free Add On | Free Add On | Costs Extra |
| Document Management | Free Add On | Free Add On | Yes |
| Events Calendar | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Expense Reports | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| FAQ Management | Free Add On | Yes | No |
| File Distribution | Free Add On | Free Add On | Yes |
| Graphs and Charts | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Groupware | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Guest Book | Free Add On | Free Add On | Costs Extra |
| Help Desk / Bug Reporting | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| HTTP Proxy | Free Add On | No | Free Add On |
| In/Out Board | No | No | Yes |
| Job Postings | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Link Management | Free Add On | Yes | Yes |
| Mail Form | Yes | Yes | No |
| My Page / Dashboard | Free Add On | No | Costs Extra |
| Newsletter | Yes | Free Add On | No |
| Photo Gallery | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Polls | Free Add On | Yes | Yes |
| Product Management | Free Add On | Yes | No |
| Project Tracking | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Search Engine | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Site Map | Yes | Free Add On | Yes |
| Surveys | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Syndicated Content (RSS) | Free Add On | Yes | No |
| Tests / Quizzes | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Time Tracking | Free Add On | No | No |
| User Contributions | Yes | Yes | Limited |
| Web Services Front End | Free Add On | Yes | Yes |
| Wiki | Free Add On | Free Add On | Limited |
| Commerce | TYPO3 4.2.6 | Joomla! 1.5.10 | Imperia 8 |
| Affiliate Tracking | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Inventory Management | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Pluggable Payments | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Pluggable Shipping | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Pluggable Tax | Free Add On | Free Add On | No |
| Point of Sale | No | Free Add On | No |
| Shopping Cart | Free Add On | Free Add On | Yes |
| Subscriptions | No | Free Add On | Limited |
| Wish Lists | Free Add On | Free Add On | Limited |
Quelle: 05/2009 http://www.cmsmatrix.org/matrix/cms-matrix